[Note: This article is based on the contents of a book titled – “Decolonize India: Reimagine A New Democratic Republic Constitution for India”]
Political leaders, commentators, and pundits often use terms like “constitution,” “constitutional rights,” and “democracy” during debates on TV and in public speeches to bolster their arguments. Meanwhile, legislators and government officials engage in discussions about the constitutionality of policies, ranging from heated confrontations to lively exchanges. However, a careful review of these statements and events suggests a prevalent misunderstanding of the Constitution.
Furthermore, are the primary stakeholders—the nation’s citizens—truly connected to these discussions? Do most citizens understand their constitution, which proudly declares in its preamble, “We the people adopt and approve this constitution”? Were they involved in its creation, or did they genuinely give their consent? These questions might flicker through your mind now and then, only to fade as you turn away from the constitutional debates unfolding in legislative halls. In this article, we aim to deepen our understanding of what a constitution is, whom it serves, and how it impacts us.
What is a Constitution?
A constitution of a modern constitutional republic is sovereign. In a monarchy, the king is supreme, hence the phrase ‘God Save the King.’ In a constitutional republic, the constitution is the supreme authority. However, while a monarch is invincible and sovereign, a constitution is sovereign but not invincible. The people possess inherent rights that even the Constitution cannot infringe upon. The “people” hold the ultimate sovereign power; their consent is the source of all governmental authority, including the Constitution itself; essentially, the Constitution acts as a framework for how the people’s power is exercised by the government.
A constitution is the supreme legal framework that defines the structure, powers, functions, and limitations of a government. It also establishes the rights and duties of citizens, aiming to reflect and safeguard the nation’s core values, principles, and vision. Hence, a constitution is a set of fundamental rules that define the structure of the government or the state, the duties of those representing the state, and the powers they hold to discharge those responsibilities.
Effectively, Constitution is a “social contract” between the nation and its people:
The most crucial function of a constitution is to limit the powers of the state, preventing it from ruling tyrannically over its citizens. Essentially, the Constitution delineates the relationship between the state and the people. This relationship can be viewed as a master-servant (or principal-agent) dynamic. The United States Constitution unmistakably places the people as the principals and the state as their agent. In contrast, the Indian Constitution crafted primarily from the British rule book of 1935 that originated from prior British rule books including the codes of the British East India Company, reverses this relationship, positioning the government as the master and the people as servants of the state. This is a typical model of colonial government (a non-democratic system) where invading colonial rulers of the country serve as lords and treat the people as their servants. India has been continuing the British colonial ruler’s model even today.
On What Basis is a Nation’s Constitution Drafted?
A constitution is drafted based on:
- Historical Context: The nation’s journey through colonialism, independence, revolutions, or significant political transitions.
- Philosophy and Ideals: Foundational beliefs like liberty, equality, justice, secularism, or socialism.
- Cultural and Religious Influence: Traditions, norms, and dominant religious or spiritual values shape constitutional articles.
- Geography and Demographics: The nation’s natural resources, population size, and diversity influence governance structures.
- Economic and Technological Factors: The level of industrialization, wealth distribution, and technological advancements shape policies for growth and regulation.
- External Influences: Colonization, globalization, or ideological exchanges may contribute to the constitution’s design.
What Is the Purpose of a Constitution?
The Constitution serves multiple purposes:
- Establish Governance: Defines the political structure and allocation of power among branches of government.
- Ensure Stability: Provides a framework to resolve disputes and maintain law and order.
- Protect Rights: Guarantees fundamental rights to individuals while balancing duties to the state.
- Express National Identity: Reflects the unique heritage, aspirations, and collective wisdom of the people.
- Adapt to Change: Allows mechanisms for amendments to evolve with societal needs.
For Who is It Drafted?
A constitution is drafted for the people of a nation:
- Citizens, to protect their rights and outline their responsibilities.
- Governments, to define their powers and limits.
- Future generations, to provide continuity, stability, and a framework for sustainable progress.
How Is It Generally Drafted?
- Formation of a Constituent Assembly: Representatives are selected or elected to represent diverse groups.
- Study and Research:
- Analysis of other constitutions.
- Inputs from historical, cultural, and legal experts.
- Drafting Process:
- Principles and values are articulated.
- Articles are written and debated.
- Public Consultation:
- Opinions are gathered through referendums, public meetings, or written submissions.
- Final Approval:
- Constituent Assembly, legislature, or a referendum ratifies the draft.
Who Should Draft It and/or Give Input?
- Constituent Assembly: Comprising representatives from all sections of society.
- Experts and Scholars: Specialists in law, economics, history, and social sciences.
- Civic Participation: Inputs from citizens to ensure the constitution aligns with their aspirations and realities.
- Stakeholders: Minority groups, indigenous communities, and others with unique needs should have representation.
- Philosophers and Visionaries: Individuals who can envision long-term principles.
Who Gives Final Approval?
The final approval of a constitution can come from:
- The People: Through a referendum to ensure legitimacy.
- Legislative Bodies: The parliament or an equivalent governing body.
- Head of State: In some systems, the formal adoption is completed by the executive or symbolic ratification by a monarch or president.
Dynamic Nature of Constitutions
It is imperative and logical that a nation’s constitution must be dynamic, reflecting changes in history, heritage, culture, geography, and socio-economic factors. Unlike religious texts, which are often considered immutable and follow universal principles within their faith, constitutions must evolve to address:
- Internal Factors: Economic shifts, cultural developments, and changes in social attitudes.
- External Influences: Globalization, wars, colonization, and technological advancements.
For instance:
- India: Amended over 100 times since 1950 to adapt to changing realities.
- USA: Despite being rigid, its interpretation evolves through judicial review.
Key Considerations for Drafting a Nation’s Constitution
A nation’s constitution is its most profound legal and moral document, designed to define the framework of governance and the relationship between the state and its people. For a constitution to be effective, just, and enduring, it must be rooted in the unique characteristics and aspirations of the nation it governs. Failure to account for these factors often leads to flaws, necessitating frequent or erroneous amendments, as evidenced in the histories of countries like India and the United States. Below, we delve into the essential considerations in drafting a nation’s constitution.
Historical Context
A nation’s history serves as the bedrock of its constitution. It captures lessons learned from colonial rule, independence movements, revolutions, and other significant political transitions. History offers insights into past struggles, the values upheld during these times, and the societal expectations of governance. For instance, India’s constitution, deeply influenced by its colonial past, borrowed heavily from the Government of India Act of 1935. This reliance on a colonial framework has often been criticized for failing to fully address India’s indigenous governance models, leading to systemic issues.
Heritage, Culture, and Traditions
A nation’s heritage and cultural ethos are its defining features. Traditions, social norms, and practices must resonate within the constitutional framework to ensure societal acceptance and stability. When a constitution overlooks the cultural and philosophical foundations of a society, it risks alienating its citizens. For example, India’s ancient democratic traditions and rich philosophical heritage were largely ignored in favor of Western governance models. Similarly, the U.S. Constitution’s initial failure to address indigenous governance systems led to significant disenfranchisement.
Geography and Demographics
The physical and demographic landscape of a nation dictates its administrative and policy requirements. Geography influences natural resource management, disaster preparedness, and regional autonomy, while demographics—diversity in ethnicity, language, and religion—demand inclusive policies. India’s diverse population and vast geography posed unique challenges, yet its constitution has often struggled to balance centralization with regional autonomy, leading to tensions between states and the central government.
Economic and Technological Considerations
Economic structures and technological advancement shape the aspirations and capacities of a nation. Constitutions must address wealth distribution, industrialization, and innovation. The U.S. Constitution, while revolutionary in its time, did not anticipate the economic disparities and technological complexities of the modern era, resulting in contentious amendments and judicial interpretations to adapt to contemporary realities.
Social Structures and Collective Wisdom
The social fabric, including class, caste, and community dynamics, profoundly influences governance. A constitution must strive to dismantle oppressive systems while preserving social harmony. For instance, India’s caste-based reservations system, while addressing historical injustices, has become a subject of political manipulation and social tension. Similarly, the U.S. Constitution’s initial compromise on slavery revealed the danger of neglecting social justice in foundational laws.
Collective Vision and Wisdom
A nation’s collective vision—what it aspires to become—must guide its constitutional values. This requires drawing on the wisdom of its people, including scholars, activists, and grassroots communities. A lack of genuine consultation often results in a disconnect between constitutional ideals and societal realities.
Flaws of Omission
The Indian Constitution highlights the consequences of neglecting foundational considerations:
The drafter of the constitution overly relied on colonial legal frameworks and the failure to integrate indigenous governance philosophies led to a system struggling with inequality, corruption, and inefficiency.
In Conclusion, a constitution is more than a legal document—it is a nation’s moral compass, reflecting its identity and aspirations. For a constitution to endure and serve its people effectively, it must be crafted with a comprehensive understanding of the nation’s history, heritage, culture, geography, demographics, economics, technological progress, and social structures. When these elements are inadequately addressed, the Constitution becomes prone to flaws, necessitating revisions that may dilute its essence or introduce new problems. By embracing collective wisdom and indigenous values, nations can craft constitutions that are both robust and adaptable, paving the way for sustainable progress and harmony.
*****
